Disclosure: this guide is written by Shroomsy, and we make one of the mushroom coffees discussed here. Read it with that in mind, and use the checklist to compare any brand, including ours.
There are dozens of mushroom coffees now, and most "best of" lists rank them without telling you what they actually checked. This is the checklist we would use if we were shopping, followed by where Shroomsy lands on each point.
What to check on any mushroom coffee label
1. Which mushrooms, named individually
A good label lists each mushroom by name rather than hiding them in a "proprietary blend." The most common are Lion's Mane, Cordyceps, Reishi, Turkey Tail, Chaga, Shiitake and King Trumpet. If you want a particular one, make sure it is actually on the list.
2. Fruiting body or mycelium
Mushroom powders come from the fruiting body (the mushroom you would recognize), the mycelium (the root network, often grown on grain), or both. Brands that use fruiting body usually say so. If a label doesn't say, it's fair to ask the brand directly.
3. Caffeine per serving
Most mushroom coffees contain less caffeine than a cup of drip coffee because part of every scoop is mushroom powder and other ingredients. If you're sensitive to caffeine, or you want a full-strength cup, check the number instead of assuming.
4. What else is in the scoop
Many blends add MCT oil, coconut milk, creamer powders or sweeteners. None of these are bad, but they change the taste, the calories and the allergen list. Coconut, for example, is labeled as a tree nut.
5. Price per serving, not price per bag
Bags range from 20 to 60 servings, so the sticker price misleads. Divide by the serving count. For reference, Ryze, the best-known brand, lists $0.90 per serving on its own site as of September 27, 2026.
6. Guarantee and testing
Look for a money-back guarantee that covers opened bags, since you can't judge taste without opening one. If a brand claims third-party testing, it should publish the certificate of analysis (COA) where you can read it.
Where Shroomsy lands
| Checklist item | Shroomsy |
|---|---|
| Mushrooms | Six, named: Lion's Mane, Cordyceps, Reishi, Turkey Tail, Shiitake, King Trumpet |
| Other ingredients | Coffee, MCT oil, coconut milk. Contains tree nuts (coconut). Gluten-free, dairy-free, soy-free. |
| Serving | One heaping tablespoon (6 g), 27 calories |
| Caffeine | About 50 mg per serving, roughly half a standard cup of coffee |
| Servings per bag | 30 |
| Price per serving | About $0.73 ($21.99 per bag) |
| Guarantee | 30-day money-back guarantee, opened bags included, free return shipping |
| Testing | Third-party testing is in progress. We'll publish the COA here when it's done, and we won't claim it until then. |
How to make it
Stir one heaping tablespoon into 6 to 8 oz of hot or cold water. Add creamer or sweetener if you like. The taste is mellow and slightly earthy, with a hint of coconut.
The honest bottom line
The "best" mushroom coffee is the one whose label matches what you want and whose taste you'll actually drink every morning. Use the checklist above on any brand. If Shroomsy fits, you can try a bag with our 30-day guarantee.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.